# **Kylebooker Whiting Cree Saddle Hackle 100 Packs #18, 20: A Cost-Effective Choice for Fly Tiers?**
As an avid fly fisherman, I’m always on the lookout for high-quality materials that offer both performance and value. Recently, I came across the **Kylebooker Whiting Cree Saddle Hackle 100 Packs in sizes #18 and #20**, which piqued my interest. But how does this product stack up in terms of cost-effectiveness? Let’s dive into a detailed analysis.
## **Understanding the Product: What Is Whiting Cree Saddle Hackle?**
Before assessing its value, it’s important to understand what makes **Whiting Cree Saddle Hackle** special. Saddle hackle feathers are prized in fly tying for their flexibility, durability, and natural beauty. The **Cree** variant is particularly sought after due to its unique barred coloration—blending shades of brown, black, and ginger—which mimics many natural insects, making it ideal for tying dry flies, nymphs, and streamers.
Whiting Farms, the producer of these feathers, is renowned for breeding genetically superior chickens that yield high-quality hackle. Their feathers are known for their **consistent barb length, stiffness, and vibrant colors**, making them a favorite among professional and amateur fly tiers alike.
## **Price vs. Quantity: Is the 100-Pack Worth It?**
The **Kylebooker Whiting Cree Saddle Hackle** comes in a bulk pack of 100 feathers, which raises the question: **Is this a cost-effective purchase compared to buying smaller quantities?**
### **Price Comparison**
– A **standard Whiting saddle patch** (smaller pack) might contain 10-20 feathers and cost around **$15-$30**, depending on size and grade.
– The **100-pack** is priced higher upfront (typically **$80-$120**, depending on the retailer), but when broken down per feather, it’s significantly cheaper—potentially **$0.80-$1.20 per feather** compared to **$1.50+ per feather** in smaller packs.
For fly tiers who go through a lot of hackle, buying in bulk can lead to **long-term savings**. However, if you only tie flies occasionally, a smaller pack might be more practical.
## **Quality Assessment: Does Bulk Mean Lower Quality?**
One concern with bulk purchases is whether the feathers are **consistent in quality**. Whiting Farms is known for its strict grading system:
– **Pro Grade**: The highest quality, with stiff barbs and uniform length—ideal for dry flies.
– **Heavy Grade**: Slightly softer, better suited for wet flies and streamers.
The **Kylebooker 100-pack** appears to be a mix of **Pro and Heavy Grade**, meaning some feathers may be stiffer than others. While this isn’t necessarily a downside (different flies require different hackle stiffness), those seeking **only top-tier dry fly hackle** might prefer buying smaller, graded packs.
## **Sizes #18 and #20: Ideal for Small Flies**
The **#18 and #20 sizes** are perfect for tying **small mayflies, midges, and other delicate patterns**. These sizes are in high demand, making the bulk purchase even more appealing. However, if you primarily tie larger flies (e.g., #12 and up), this pack may not be the best fit.
## **Final Verdict: Is It a Good Value?**
### **Pros:**
✔ **Cost per feather is lower than smaller packs**—great for frequent fly tiers.
✔ **Whiting’s reputation ensures reliable quality** (even if not all feathers are Pro Grade).
✔ **Cree coloration is versatile**—works for many insect imitations.
✔ **Convenient for tiers who need a steady supply of small hackle (#18-#20).**
### **Cons:**
✖ **Higher upfront cost**—may not suit casual tiers.
✖ **Mixed grades**—some feathers may be softer than expected.
✖ **Limited size range**—not ideal for those who tie larger flies.
### **Who Should Buy It?**
– **Fly shops or commercial tiers** who need bulk supplies.
– **Dedicated anglers** who tie small dry flies frequently.
– **Those who appreciate the Cree pattern** and want a long-lasting stock.
### **Who Might Skip It?**
– **Beginners** who are still experimenting with different materials.
– **Anglers who prefer larger flies** (sizes #12 and up).
– **Tiers who demand only Pro Grade hackle** for dry flies.
## **Conclusion: A Solid Investment for the Right Angler**
The **Kylebooker Whiting Cree Saddle Hackle 100 Pack in #18 and #20** offers **excellent value for serious fly tiers** who need a steady supply of small hackle. While the upfront cost is higher, the **per-feather savings** and **Whiting’s reliable quality** make it a smart purchase for those who tie frequently. However, if you only tie occasionally or prefer larger flies, smaller packs might be a better fit.
For me, as someone who ties a lot of **small mayfly and midge patterns**, this bulk pack seems like a worthwhile investment. The **Cree coloration** adds an extra layer of realism to my flies, and the cost savings over time make it a **budget-friendly choice in the long run**.
Would you consider buying this pack? Let me know your thoughts—tight lines and happy tying!
